NYC Public Defenders Joint Statement on DOI Investigation of Wrongly Recorded Phone Calls in NYC Jails
“The widespread, illegal practice described in this investigation undermined one of the most fundamental tenets of the constitutional right to counsel: the ability of people to receive confidential advice from their legal team. Thousands of confidential phone calls between incarcerated people and their attorneys were wrongly recorded, and many were even supplied to district attorneys, the NYPD, and other law enforcement agencies.
“The Department of Investigation is correct that this improper recording of phone calls was ‘unacceptable.’ However, this investigation and its conclusions are simply inadequate.
“We are disappointed that this report limited its scope of review to documents provided by DOC and Securus and failed to interview affected defender organizations and impacted New Yorkers who could attest to the consequences of this illegal recording practice. The investigation also failed to adequately address Securus’s long history of civil liberties violations and data breaches, as well as the litany of harms caused by the company’s extensive surveillance networks. We know, based on Securus’s history in New York and across the country, that this is a company that cannot be trusted.
“While NYC made the historic step to make phone calls in city jails free for all incarcerated people in 2019, this significant breach underscores that the societal costs of recording phone calls remains great.
“DOC records every phone call involving an incarcerated person, excluding - they claim - calls involving numbers included on its ‘Do Not Record’ list, such as those belonging to defense teams. Even if legal calls were properly protected, universal recording of people in jails is a violation of privacy and subjects incarcerated people, their friends, and family members—overwhelmingly from Black and Latine communities—to undue monitoring and control.
“One of the most troubling aspects of the universal recording project is the collection of biometric data known as ‘voiceprints.’ These speech patterns of incarcerated people and those they call are saved to a central database by Securus, along with call recordings and other personal information. Logging over 30,000 calls per day, Securus’s biometric database of New Yorkers is immense and ever growing.
“Equally concerning is that, following this breach of confidential phone calls and the inability to properly safeguard the privacy of New Yorkers, the city decided to expand Securus’s services to include tablets and proposed mail scanning and, thus, enlarge Securus’s surveillance web.
“The recommendations offered by the DOI do not adequately protect people’s privacy. New York City should not only end its troubling contract with Securus, but also cease the practice of universally recording calls made by incarcerated New Yorkers. DOC has proven it cannot be trusted with protecting privileged calls or respecting basic notions of privacy. The city must end — once and for all — the recording of all phone calls placed by people in jail. Restoring privacy protections would not hamstring legitimate law enforcement investigations. But it would put an end to unlimited, unfettered recording of phone calls as the default. Listening to another individual’s personal conversations should be the exception, not the rule. Restore privacy, restore confidence, restore basic human dignity. It is well past time.”
Brooklyn Defender Services Helps to Ring in the School Year in East New YorkBrooklyn Defender Services was thrilled to kick off the 2023 school year in spectacular fashion alongside our community partners for the “It Takes a Village Back-To-School Giveaway" on September 2nd at Success Community Gardens.Events
NYC Family Defense Providers Submit Joint Testimony to the New York Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights on Racism Within Family Court and the Family Policing SystemThe Bronx Defenders, Brooklyn Defender Services, Center for Family Representation, and the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem submitted joint testimony on racism within the family policing system to the New York Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, which is conducting an investigation of “the New York Child Welfare System and its impact on Black Children and Families.”Press Releases
New York City Public Defenders’ Joint Statement on the Crisis on Rikers and the Need for ReceivershipNew York County Defender Services, The Bronx Defenders, Brooklyn Defender Services, Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, and Queens Defenders issued a joint statement regarding the ongoing humanitarian crisis on Rikers Island.Press Releases
Sweltering Summer Weather Stirs Familiar Concerns Over Heat in NYC Jails“It’s an issue that seems to be within DOC’s control, something they can anticipate,” said Lucas Marquez, director of civil rights and law reform at Brooklyn Defender Services. “And yet they’re really not able to make sure that the conditions are humane for the people that are forced to be there.”In The NewsBail & Pre-Trial Incarceration
Brooklyn Defender Services and New York County Defender Services Joint Statement on William Johnstone, the Sixth Person to Die in New York City Jails in 2023Brooklyn Defender Services and New York County Defender Services released the following joint statement following reports of the death of William Johnstone, a client of Brooklyn Defender Services and New York County Defender Services, who was the sixth person to die in Department of Correction (DOC) custody this year.Press Releases
Op-ed: Keeping families together is best - June is National Family Preservation Month"In June, families across the country are honoring National Family Preservation Month, recognizing the importance of the work being done to keep families together. To keep the city’s children safe, we must support — not tear apart — their families and communities."In The News
Testimony: The New York City Council Committee on Education Oversight Hearing on Legislation related to Students in the Foster SystemHannah Mercuris, Senior Attorney in the Education Practice at Brooklyn Defender Services (BDS), testified before the New York City Council Committee on Education Oversight Hearing on Legislation related to Students in the Foster SystemLetters & TestimoniesEducation Rights
With the City’s FY24 Budget Due Next Friday, Public Defenders and Civil Legal Services Providers Call on Mayor Adams to Support Increased Funding to Meet Widespread Staffing and Operational NeedsNew York City’s leading public defender and civil legal services organizations called on Mayor Eric Adams to support increased funding in the City’s Fiscal Year 2024 budget to address insufficient funding levels, wage inequality, and rising costs which jeopardize low-income New Yorkers’ access to critical legal services.Press Releases
Preserving Family Bonds Act Passes the New York State LegislatureA coalition of families impacted by the foster system and advocates for parents and young people hail the passage of the Preserving Family Bonds Act (A5394 - Joyner / S6720 - Brisport) in the New York State Legislature. The bill passed in the NYS Assembly on June 21st and in the NYS Senate on May 22nd. The Preserving Family Bonds Coalition urges Governor Hochul to immediately sign the act into law.Press Releases