NYC child welfare agency still citing marijuana in family separations despite legalization, state policy change
Marijuana was legalized statewide in March 2021. Many Democrats rallied around the racial equity that legalization was supposed to bring. The law enshrined what was already supposed to have been ACS policy for years: No parent shall be found neglectful only because they use marijuana, without proving harm or its potential to the child.
But court records and interviews with people directly involved in ACS proceedings suggest New York City’s child welfare system has been slow to change since changing its policy and since legalization, with marijuana continuing to be used as a cudgel against families, attorneys leaning on old taboos, and family court judges allowing outmoded ideas about marijuana to persist.
“We have seen ACS interrogate the validity of the prescription both by wanting to speak directly with a doctor, or questioning the veracity or authenticity of the prescription — and then taking it a step further by even questioning the medical decision to prescribe the marijuana,” said Nila Natarajan, supervising attorney and policy counsel of Brooklyn Defender Services’ Family Defense Practice.
When asked about the claim, ACS repeated its assertion that it looks at all cases in the context of child safety.
But Natarajan and others argue that the agency portrays these parents as using marijuana to self-medicate and as therefore showing signs of mental instability.
"Let's say that parent also sees a mental health professional,” Natarajan said. “We have seen ACS go to the mental health professional and say, 'Oh, do you know this person is prescribed marijuana? What's your assessment of their marijuana use? Is it really OK for them to be using marijuana?'"
The cannabis bill signed into state law in 2021 notes that “the sole fact that an individual consumes cannabis, without a separate finding that the child's physical mental or emotional condition was impaired or is in imminent danger of becoming impaired … shall not be sufficient” for proving neglect.
But critics say ACS continues to flout the new measures.
View the full Gothamist article here.
Advocates raise concerns about NYPD’s enhanced use of pedestrian stops to tamp down on guns“The encounters become very aggressive and then you have people getting charged with resisting arrest or obstructing governmental administration,” said Yung-Mi Lee, an attorney with Brooklyn Defender Services.In The NewsPolice Accountability
Bill to Require Mental Health Staff at Family Shelters Spurs Worry Over ‘Unintended Effects’“We’re concerned that introducing mental health professionals who are mandated reporters directly into family shelters, which are people’s homes, will inadvertently increase surveillance of families" Alexandra Dougherty of Brooklyn Defenders said.In The NewsEarly Defense for Parents Facing ACS Investigations
Brooklyn Defender Services Statement on Kevin Bryan, the 14th Person to Die in NYC Jails in 2022We are absolutely devastated by the death of Kevin Bryan who died on Wednesday after seven days of incarceration in a Rikers Island jail. We grieve with his family, friends, and all who are affected by his death.Press ReleasesBail & Pre-Trial Incarceration
Brooklyn Defender Services Statement on Brooklyn DA’s Vacatur of Over 375 Convictions Involving 13 NYPD Officers Guilty of MisconductWe urge DA Gonzalez and district attorneys across the city to continue to conduct full and transparent reviews of convictions involving officers who are known to have committed misconduct.Press ReleasesPolice Accountability
BDS Testimony before New York City Council Committees on Health regarding the Monkeypox Virus in New York CityWe are here today to raise our concern for the health of the hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers who live or are detained in congregate and institutional settings, including the city’s jails, juvenile detention facilities, shelters, residential treatment programs, and foster homes. Letters & TestimoniesBail & Pre-Trial Incarceration
BDS Testimony before New York City Council Committee on General Welfare regarding Long-Standing NYC Shelter Intake Issues and the Recent Increase in Asylum SeekersToday's hearing was prompted by the recent arrival of many asylum seekers to New York and the city’s shelters lack of preparedness to assist people in need of emergency housing.Letters & TestimoniesTenant Rights and Housing Discrimination
City ordered to pay Rikers detainees who were denied medical appointmentsA state judge has ordered the city’s Department of Correction to pay out fines to individuals on Rikers Island who were deprived of medical appointments, an unusual penalty that underscores the depth of medical neglect within the city’s troubled jail system.In The NewsBail & Pre-Trial Incarceration
Legal Aid Society, Brooklyn Defender Services and Milbank LLP Hail Court Order Requiring NYC Department of Correction to Pay Roughly $200,000 in Fines to New Yorkers Who Were Denied Access to Medical Treatment in City JailsDOC held in contempt of court for failing to ensure that incarcerated New Yorkers have access to medical care in NYC jails.Press ReleasesBail & Pre-Trial Incarceration
NYIFUP Providers Condemn ICE's Reckless and Dangerous Transfers from Orange County Correctional Facility, Demand Immediate Release of All People from the Facility"ICE’s decision to transfer detained immigrant New Yorkers from the Orange County Correctional Facility to unknown locations outside of the NYC area, without any prior notice to detained people’s families or legal counsel, is reckless and unsafe."Press ReleasesImmigration Raids & Detention