“Cut Ties With ICE!”: Electeds, Advocates, and Impacted Communities Rally Behind Legislative Package After City Council Hearing
“Cut Ties With ICE!”: Electeds, Advocates, and Impacted Communities Rally Behind Legislative Package After City Council Hearing
Immigrants' Rights
The “Cut Ties With ICE!” package would restrict the City from colluding with ICE and from using city resources to funnel New Yorkers into detention and deportation
NEW YORK CITY – Today, following the New York City Council’s immigration hearing, elected officials, immigrants’ rights advocates, and impacted communities rallied at City Hall in support of the “Cut Ties With ICE!” legislative package – three bills (Intros. 1078-A, 1077-A, and 209) that would cut off New York City’s deportation pipeline by restricting the City from colluding with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and from using city resources to funnel people into detention and deportation.
After years of advocacy to protect New York’s immigrant communities, New York City currently boasts strong, bipartisan sanctuary laws that have protected countless New Yorkers. But gaps exist, and the “Cut Ties With ICE” package would strengthen our laws by establishing judicial warrant requirements for ICE; a mechanism for City accountability when local laws are violated; and an assurance that local tax dollars are used for local needs, not to assist ICE operations.
Today’s action follows the horrific ICE violence in the Bronx earlier this fall. On October 8, ICE officers wearing street clothes and masks stopped Oscar Belgal and fired multiple rounds into his car, hitting him in the neck as his five-year-old son watched. Since then, advocates, electeds, and communities impacted by ICE have demanded the City take immediate, decisive action to cut ties with ICE.
Quotes from organizations, electeds, and impacted communities are as follows:
“ICE is a violent, rogue, unaccountable agency that has no place in New York City,” said Donna Lieberman, Executive Director of the New York Civil Liberties Union. “New York communities have been built by generations of immigrant love, ingenuity, creativity, and resilience — and ICE cannot scare, brutalize, or beat that out of us. We call on Mayor Mamdani and the City Council to pass the ‘Cut Ties With ICE’ package so every New Yorker can live with freedom, safety, and dignity.”
“New Yorkers have made it clear that we refuse to be complicit as ICE’s violent terror tactics tear families apart. We welcome the call from a growing number of elected officials to abolish ICE, and yet we must go further than calling for it to be abolished: we must cut off the sources that funnel our neighbors to ICE in the first place,” said Yasmine Farhang, Executive Director of the Immigrant Defense Project. “The Cut Ties with ICE legislative package is critical to strengthen current sanctuary laws that have not been updated in over a decade and will take meaningful steps in this moment to ensure New Yorkers can trust their city agencies not to funnel them to ICE’s deadly hands.”
“If we really believe New York is a city for immigrants, then city agencies should not be aiding ICE operations,” said Ben Brodsky, a member of Jews For Racial & Economic Justice (JFREJ). “If NYC wants to stay true to our sanctuary laws, it is imperative that this Council codify these protections with regard to the NYPD and the Department of Correction, to prevent these agencies from exploiting loopholes any further. Countless Jewish New Yorkers, including my great-grandparents, were given safe haven in New York when they arrived in the United States. Today, we call on our city to cut ties with ICE for good and ensure NYC remains a beacon of freedom.”
“For five years, we have shared stories with the City Council about New Yorkers who were funneled into ICE custody by the NYPD and DOC because of loopholes that exist in our laws,” said Rosa Cohen-Cruz, Immigration Policy Director at The Bronx Defenders. “They are the stories of New Yorkers who don’t make the headlines, but for their families and communities, the fact that the City was involved is eroding trust and creating fear. By passing these laws and completely cutting ties with ICE, the City can convincingly reassert that it refuses to participate in ICE’s campaign of terror.”
“ICE’s actions are taking an enormous toll on our communities with every neighbor they intimidate and every family they separate,” said Randy Ali, CEO of the Arab-American Family Support Center. “We refuse to accept that a federal agency can come into our city and our homes, break families apart, and tear at our social fabric. The City must do its part to ensure that public resources are used to protect our communities, not facilitate detention and deportation. Let’s send a clear signal that New York City stands with our immigrant neighbors.”
“Every New Yorker deserves due process no matter their race, background or immigration status,” said Murad Awawdeh, President & CEO, New York Immigration Coalition. “As ICE continues to escalate its attacks against our immigrant neighbors, New York City must strengthen its protection of all New Yorkers and ensure our tax dollars are invested in our communities – not used to tear families apart. ICE should not be able to rely on our local agencies to do its dirty work for it. If ICE wants to arrest a New Yorker, they should get a warrant signed by a judge. New York City cannot be an extension of ICE’s mass detention and deportation machine. By passing this legislative package, New York City can close loopholes in its sanctuary laws and hold City agencies accountable when they violate those protections. The City can lead and show the rest of the country what it means to strengthen due process protections for all New Yorkers.”
“When ICE agents shot Oscar Belgal in Marble Hill in front of his five-year-old son, they made clear how little regard this administration has for the safety of New Yorkers,” said Brad Hoylman-Sigal, Manhattan Borough President. “Our City has a responsibility to do everything in its power to protect our immigrant neighbors. That’s why I’m calling on the City Council to pass the Cut Ties With ICE package, which would ensure the City does not unduly facilitate the detention of immigrants, hold City agencies accountable when our sanctuary laws are violated, and keep New Yorkers’ tax dollars from funding ICE operations. New York is a city of immigrants, and we will use every tool at our disposal to keep our neighbors safe.”
“As ICE escalates its violent targeting of New Yorkers, it’s critical that the City Council take serious steps to protect our immigrant neighbors,” said Council Member Lincoln Restler. “We need to start by passing this legislative package, which would limit the NYPD’s ability to help ICE arrest New Yorkers, limit the Department of Correction’s communications with ICE, and create a pathway for immigrant New Yorkers harmed by immigration detainers to seek justice.”
“We must close the loopholes that allow for ICE to terrorize our communities,” said Council Member Alexa Avilés. “NYC is a sanctuary city because we are an immigrant city. Every person who lives here should feel safe to go about their daily lives and access our public services. Any failing of our sanctuary laws to provide that dignity and justice is a problem we must resolve as the City Council. Thank you to the organizers of the ICE Out! Coalition who have kept the safety and health of New Yorkers at the heart of their legislative package.”
“New York City cannot help an agency that shoots a father in front of his child,” said Council Member Julie Won. “On October 8, masked ICE officers in street clothes shot Oscar Belgal in the neck as his five-year-old son watched from the car. Immigrant families must be able to share personal information with city agencies without fear that ICE will get it. Our sanctuary laws need to catch up to how ICE operates now. City Council must pass Intros 1078-A, 1077-A, and 209, and Mayor Mamdani must sign them.”
“New York City has some of the strongest sanctuary laws in the country, and they’ve protected countless families,” said Majority Leader Shaun Abreu. “This package builds on that foundation, updating protections and clarifying our rules to make sure we are meeting the moment and protecting our neighbors. I’m proud to stand with my colleagues and our city’s advocates to ensure our city’s resources serve New Yorkers, not deportation.”
“State protections for immigrant families are only as strong as the local policies that support them. When city rules fall short, federal agents and the agencies that assist them find room to operate in the cracks. That is unacceptable,” said Assemblymember Karines Reyes, RN, Assembly prime sponsor of the New York for All/Dignity Not Detention Laws. “Due process is a right that belongs to every New Yorker, and we have a responsibility to ensure it is granted, regardless of status. Accountability ought to be enforced on authorities who so often violate local laws. Assurances that our tax dollars are used to support our needs, not to aid operations that put our communities in danger. New York City must be firm in its opposition to ICE and pass these council protections immediately.”
“When city agencies still find ways to assist ICE in kidnapping and deporting our neighbors, our sanctuary laws are rendered meaningless. I have seen firsthand how this collaboration impacts families in my district, including the detention of parents in front of their children and the loss of community members’ trust in the very institutions that are supposed to protect and serve them,” said Assemblywoman Catalina Cruz. “No New Yorker should fear that reaching out to their local government for help may tear their family apart. The Cut Ties With ICE package would make it plain that city agencies must respect our sanctuary laws and close the loopholes that allow collaboration to continue. Public resources should serve New Yorkers, not help ICE carry out its deportation agenda. We have a responsibility to make sure every New Yorker, regardless of immigration status, trusts the city they call home.”
“Our immigrant neighbors should be able to turn to their city for help without fearing that doing so could get them separated from their families,” said Council Member Christopher Marte. “Every city dollar and every city agency should serve the people who live here. We have no business helping ICE terrorize our communities, and we cannot leave loopholes in our laws that allow that cooperation to continue. Let’s pass this package and make good on the protection we’ve promised New Yorkers.”
“New York City’s long-standing sanctuary laws protect immigrant communities from being detained and deported without due process. Today, the Council has the opportunity to strengthen these vital protections to ensure that ICE officers adhere to the law before depriving someone of their liberty,” said Deborah Lee, Attorney-in-Charge of the Immigration Law Unit at The Legal Aid Society. “ICE has shown that it will use any pretext to carry out mass deportations. The Council must close the detainer law loopholes and protect all of Legal Aid’s clients from being funneled into our cruel, inhumane immigration system.”
“No part of our City should collaborate with ICE,” said Council Member Sandy Nurse. “Their very presence puts all New Yorkers – not just immigrants – at risk of physical harm and having their constitutional rights further eroded under this President. While our ultimate goal is to abolish ICE, we can help prevent any part of our city from aiding and abetting their behavior by passing this legislation.”
“NYC has long been recognized as a sanctuary city for immigrants, and its sanctuary laws are an essential tool to protect immigrant New Yorkers from the increasingly cruel harms of ICE arrest and detention,” said Josh Epstein, the Director of the Immigration Practice at Brooklyn Defender Services’ (BDS) Queens Office. “The Cut Ties With ICE legislative package would close dangerous gaps in the law that allow the NYPD and DOC to funnel New Yorkers into the deportation machine. We call on the Council and Mayor to take action to protect the rights of immigrant New Yorkers by enacting these bills immediately.”
“When city agencies violate our sanctuary laws, lives are destroyed,” said Scott Foletta, Managing Director of the Immigration Defense Team at the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem. “It is more important than ever for New York City to draw a clear line: we will not be complicit in ICE’s violent, racist attacks on our immigrant communities.”
“ICE’s presence in New York City harms immigrant youth in our community. So many young New Yorkers and their families have been detained and deported through ICE’s cruel actions,” said Beth Baltimore, Interim Managing Director of The Door’s Legal Services Center. “ICE has torn apart families and has shown that they will do anything to carry out its mass deportation agenda. The Council must close the gaps in the detainer laws to protect The Door’s young members and their families.”
“To stand idly by while Federal ICE Agents continue to terrorize our friends, families, and neighbors only further degrades the trust New Yorkers place in their government officials who they elected to enact policies that protect them. If we do not act now, New York remains an accomplice to criminal, unjust, and inhumane attacks on Immigrant New Yorkers,” said Council Member Amanda Farías. “As a sponsor and supporter of the full Cut Ties With ICE package, I’m proud to be a part of the crew of policymakers in the city council prepared to bring balance back to the scales of justice with strategic legislative action against ICE.”
“With ICE raiding streets and shooting up blocks from Minneapolis to Marble Hill, our immigrant communities have been forced back into the shadows. But in The World’s Borough, where half of us were born abroad, we uplift and defend our immigrant neighbors, both with our voices and with critical legislation like this package of bills,” said Queens Borough President Donovan Richards Jr. “Not only does ICE need to get the hell out of town, ICE needs to be defunded and abolished once and for all. But until that day comes, we’ll keep fighting to hold agents accountable for law-breaking and to further prevent city agencies from cooperating with this rogue agency.”
“The tragic shooting of Oscar Belgal is a devastating reminder that we can’t afford to leave anyone behind when it comes to keeping New Yorkers safe,” said State Senator Andrew Gounardes. “Our local government shouldn’t be deputized to carry out ICE’s mass deportation agenda, and no New Yorker should have to fear that the city agencies tasked with protecting them might instead put them in harm’s way. The Cut Ties With ICE package can help us close legal loopholes to prevent federal immigration authorities from exploiting local resources and tearing immigrant families apart. By passing these laws, we can send a clear message that New Yorkers stick together—whether our families came here generations ago or just last week.”
“Trump’s fascist agenda terrorizes our immigrant communities and rips families apart,” said Intro. 209 Sponsor, Council Member Shahana Hanif. “Our sanctuary laws exist to keep our communities safe, but without teeth, we’ve repeatedly seen these safeguards ignored by city agencies. My bill, the NYC Trust Act, would hold the NYPD, DOC, and DOP accountable to the laws already on the books by creating a private right of action–empowering those whose rights have been violated to bring suit and seek justice.”